The weather in Buffalo this past week has proven that summer is pretty much over. Confirmation of that fact also comes with the end of the Major League Baseball season.
2009 was an odd year for baseball fans. There were plenty of outstanding performances and milestones, but - outside of the American League Central - there weren’t any stirring pennant or Wild-Card races.
Anyway, the end of the season also brings the annual debate about who should receive the major awards – Most Valuable Player and Cy Young - in the American and National Leagues.
While I may not have a vote, I still have opinions, and here is my breakdown of who should win the major awards in each league:
American League Most Valuable Player – New York Yankees’ captain Derek Jeter entered the 2009 season with a career batting average of .316, but the 35-year old seemed to have gotten a little better with age in 2009. Entering Wednesday, he ranked third in the A.L. with a .333 average and was also third in the league with 64 multi-hit games.
Placed in the leadoff role for the first time since 2005, Jeter also has reached the 30-steal plateau for only the fourth time in his career. It may come off as some sort of Lifetime Achievement prize, but Jeter in 2009 truly deserves to be the A.L. MVP.
American League Cy Young Award – It’s hard to be the ace on a team that went nowhere after flirting with a division lead through May, but Zach Greinke of the Kansas City Royals was solid the whole season. He has still won two-thirds of his decisions (16-8) and leads the league with a 2.06 earned run average.
Opponents are only batting .229 against him, the second-best rate in the league behind the Yankees’ fellow Cy Young contender CC Sabathia. But Greinke has 43 more strikeouts than Sabathia and also twirled three shutouts to tie Roy Halladay for the league lead. It should all add up to Kansas City’s first Cy Young winner since David Cone in 1994.
National League Most Valuable Player – It would be hard to argue if St. Louis Cardinals first baseman Albert Pujols takes a second straight MVP award. A perennial Triple Crown contender, Pujols enters Wednesday ranking third in batting average (.328) and runs batted in (133) while leading the majors in home runs (47).
His slugging percentage of .668 is 75 points (!) higher than N.L. runner-up Prince Fielder (.593), and his five grand slams are by far the most in the majors – no one else has more than three.
National League Cy Young Award – The Cards should sweep the major awards, as Chris Carpenter should hold off teammate Adam Wainwright for the hardware. Carpenter’s league-leading earned run average of 2.30 isn’t the deciding factor (Wainwright ranks third at 2.58), nor should winning percentage hold sway (Carpenter is 16-4 while Wainwright is 19-8).
Carpenter gets my nod because of two things: his 11-game winning streak he posted between July 5 and September 7 (a stretch in which the Cards broke away from the pack in the N.L. Central race) and his 2.15 ERA in road games, a category in which Wainwright doesn’t even rank in the top 10.
………
The playoffs should be interesting, even though most of the chatter will be about the return of the Yankees to the post-season after a one-year absence.
The real story should be out west, where the two Los Angeles teams – the Dodgers in the National League and the Angels in the A.L. – could steamroll any foe.
The Dodgers could have a tough time if they face St. Louis, but should still be able to take the N.L. pennant. The Angels’ only real test could come against the vaunted Yankees (against whom they split their 10-game season series).
In the end, I foresee a Freeway Series where weather shouldn’t be a factor for late October games. The SoCal sideshow could be as interesting as the games, but I like the Angels to prevail in six games over the Dodgers.
